Search blog.co.uk

About me

eventsupplies

eventsupplies

Tags

Green is not always good

by eventsupplies @ 2008-05-02 - 14:54:05

 

 We have started to notice even more supposedly 'green' catering disposable products appearing on the market - notably PLA lined paper cups which are all ‘derived from natural sustainable resources’.

Many companies play on peoples’ consciences to buy these products but many do not see the big picture, that some of these products can create more waste and do more harm than good.

Putting aside the puzzling fact that parts of the world are felling trees to create space to grow corn crops to meet our demand for low CO2 produced products (who thought that one up?, -  we need the trees to convert the CO2 into oxygen!) using PLA lined paper cups can reduce the amount we recycle!

 

I will elaborate.

 

PLA lined paper cups will separate when decomposing leaving a paper ‘mulch’ and the PLA lining.

99.9% of all paper cups used at the moment are not biodegradable due to the oil based poly lining on the inside which prevent liquids seeping into the paper walls. However these cups can be recycled into some other product.

 

As I have stated in previous blogs, adding this new kind of paper cup with PLA lining into the ‘mix’, however noble the intentions, will create more waste than previously created with the oil based poly lined paper cups.

If one of these PLA cups is put into a batch of ‘normal’ paper cups

for recycling (and you cannot visibly tell the difference)  the PLA will react with the oil based poly lined materials and ruin the whole batch of paper, making it completely non recyclable!

 

So my advice is to question any company that states products they sell are helping the environment, and ask them if they have thought about what was removed from the land to create the space for their corn crops etc and how the product they produce or market is disposed of.

 

What percentage of people do you think actually take their PLA cups home and compost them? Could you even tell if you were handed a PLA cup? I doubt most people outside the industry would know.

 

 

 

 

 

*PLA paper or plastic cups will not biodegrade in landfill

*There is only one dedicated recycling company in the UK which will collect waste paper cups, and they will not touch PLA lined paper cups.

*We have spent years giving farm subsidies to farmers in Africa to help them create crops and stand on their own two feet, now we are mass producing those same crops for fuel and alternatives to plastics, lowering the price as a result, and plunging these people back into poverty.



Add Event Supplies's channel to your page

 
 

Trackback address for this post:

authimage

Comments, Trackbacks: Hide subcomments

Customer Service [Visitor]
http://www.eventsupplies.co.uk/
2008-06-02 @ 09:38

Have now started to notice Paper cup manufacturers are not shouting so much about their cups ‘Green’ credentials. Many are now stating that the PLA lined biodegradable cups will only biodegrade unused and once they are filled with coffee (or any other matter – there is a large industry for mixing auto paints in paper cups for example) they cannot claim the cups are biodegradable….

mark woodward [Visitor]
http://www.thepapercupcompany.co.uk
2008-06-11 @ 09:05

I agree with your comment, that PLA lined cups are not easy to compost, as need to be put through industrial composting facilities, but i am pleased that manufactures are finding sustainable materials to make products from, and normal plastic lined cups are not sustainable, eventually plastic will run out.
They way forward is to get cups recycled, and Save a Cup, now collect paper cups in the uk, and organisations like The Fibre Technology Association are finding routes for cups to be recycled.
PLA lined cups are easier to recycle than PE coated cups, as the pla lining breaks down more readily.
We at the paper cup company continue to support organisations like save a cup and The Fibre Technology Association as we feel this is a much better route than composting, i feel composting should be a last resort.
Regards
Mark Woodward

Don’t get me wrong....I too am pleased to see sustainable materials used to make the paper cups we use although not at the expense of forests etc. My main concern is that the introduction of said cups may create more waste as identifying between the two types of cups is difficult during the recycling process.

Unfortunately I have found that some companies describe their PLA cups as PLA lined and give the impression that the cups are wholly compostable when they are not, sometimes the base of the cups when formed are not lined with PLA as the material does not glue together well and normal oil based poly coating is applied to the base. Using both these materials in the production of the cups is going to hinder or stop any recycling attempts and is misleading.

All 100% PLA lined paper cup manufacturers should claim is that their cups are biodegradable before use. Many will not biodegrade depending on what has been put in the cup (paper cups used in the auto paint mixing industry for example definitely will not)

Leave a comment :

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.
Allowed XHTML tags: <!, p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, img>
URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.
Options:
 
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email & url)
Validation code:
Please enter the above code here:
For protection from spambots (case-sensitive).